الملخص
الاعتراض على الحکم الغیابی من الطرائق العادیة للطعن بالأحکام ، قد آثار ویثیر الکثیر من المشاکل عند نظر المحاکم للدعاوى الاعتراضیة ، سواءأ کانت تلک المشاکل تتعلق بالتبلیغات أم فی بیان أساس الاعتراض أم عزوف بعض المدعى علیهم عن الحضور وحضور البعض الآخر ، فضلاً عما یثیره موضوع حضور الخصم فی بعض الجلسات وتخلفه عن حضور الجلسات الأخیرة ، وطلب الخصم الأخر إصدار الحکم معلقاً على الاستکتاب والنکول عن الیمین . فهذا النوع من الأحکام یثیر جملة من التساؤلات ، فهل الحکم الصادر هو حکم حضوری أم أنه حکم غیابی یسمح القانون بالاعتراض علیه ؟ والبحث یعرض ویعالج المشاکل العملیة التی یثیرها موضوع الاعتراض على الحکم الغیابی ومدى جدوى هذا الطریق من طرائق الطعن
الكلمات الرئيسة
الموضوعات
أصل المقالة
الاعتراض على الحکم الغیابی -(*)-
Objection to the court judgment in absentia
نجلاء توفیق فلیح کلیة القانون/ جامعة تکریت Najlaa Tawfeq Flaeeh College of law / University of Tikrit Correspondence: Najlaa Tawfeq Flaeeh E-mail: |
(*) أستلم البحث فی 24/2/2009 *** قبل للنشر فی 7/6/2010.
(*) Received on 24/2/2009 *** accepted for publishing on 7/6/2010.
Doi: 10.33899/alaw.2011.160584
© Authors, 2011, College of Law, University of Mosul This is an open access articl under the CC BY 4.0 license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0).
الملخص
الاعتراض على الحکم الغیابی من الطرائق العادیة للطعن بالأحکام ، قد آثار ویثیر الکثیر من المشاکل عند نظر المحاکم للدعاوى الاعتراضیة ، سواءأ کانت تلک المشاکل تتعلق بالتبلیغات أم فی بیان أساس الاعتراض أم عزوف بعض المدعى علیهم عن الحضور وحضور البعض الآخر ، فضلاً عما یثیره موضوع حضور الخصم فی بعض الجلسات وتخلفه عن حضور الجلسات الأخیرة ، وطلب الخصم الأخر إصدار الحکم معلقاً على الاستکتاب والنکول عن الیمین . فهذا النوع من الأحکام یثیر جملة من التساؤلات ، فهل الحکم الصادر هو حکم حضوری أم أنه حکم غیابی یسمح القانون بالاعتراض علیه ؟ والبحث یعرض ویعالج المشاکل العملیة التی یثیرها موضوع الاعتراض على الحکم الغیابی ومدى جدوى هذا الطریق من طرائق الطعن
الکلمات الرئیسة: الحکم الغیابی الطعن بالأحکام
الموضوعات: قانون المرافعات المدنیة والاثبات
Abstract
Objections to absentee rule from the ordinary methods of appeal against the provisions have had and will raise many problems in the courts' consideration of counter-claims, whether those problems relate to communications, the basis of the objection or the reluctance of some defendants to attend and attend others, In some of the sessions and the failure to attend the last sessions, and asked the other opponent to issue a ruling on the suspension and the right to complain. This type of provision raises a number of questions. Is the ruling issued is a judgment of my presence or is it an absentee rule that the law allows objecting to it? The research presents and addresses the practical problems raised by the object of objection to absentee judgment and the feasibility of this method of appeal
Keywords: The appeal of judgments judgment in absentia
Main Subjects: civil procedure law and law of evidence
The Author declare That there is no conflict of interest
References (Arabic Translated to English)
First: Legal books
1. Ibrahim Al-Mashadi, Legal Principles in the Court of Cassation, Al-Jahez Press, Baghdad, 1990; Chosen from the Court of Cassation, Pleadings Section, Al-Zaman Press, Baghdad, 1999.
2. Ahmed Abou El Wafa, The Origins of Civil Trials, Makawi Office, Beirut, Second Edition, 1979, Civil and Commercial Procedures, 14th Al-Maaref Establishment, Alexandria, 1986.
3. Ahmad Hendi, Civil and Commercial Procedure, University House, 1989
4. Amina Al-Nimr, Civil Procedure, I 2 Irons Office, Beirut 1979, p. 743.
5. d. Ahmed El-Sayy El-Sawy, Al-Wisad in Explaining the Law of Civil and Commercial Procedures, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo University Press and University Book, 1981
6. Rahim Hussein Al-Okaili, objections, Sabah Library, Baghdad, without printing year.
7. Saadoun Naji al-Qashtini, Explanation of the provisions of the Code of Procedure, vol. 1, Al-Ma'arif Press, Baghdad, 1972.
۸. Mr. Munir Al-Qadi, Explanation of the Code of Civil and Commercial Procedure, 1st Floor, Al-Ani Press, Baghdad, 1957
9. Sadiq Haider, Explanation of the Code of Civil Procedure, Lectures given to students of the Judicial Institute, Ministry of Justice Judicial Institute, Baghdad 1986
10. Dia Shit Khattab, Research and Studies in Iraqi Civil Procedure Law, Institute of Arab Studies Research, 1970; Brief Description of Civil Procedure Law, Baghdad, 1973.
11. Abbas Aboudi, Explanation of the provisions of the Civil Procedure Law, Comparative and Enhanced Study of Judicial Applications, Mosul University, 2000.
۱۲. Abdul Jalil Bertu, Explanation of the Code of Civil and Commercial Procedures, Islamic Printing and Publishing Co., Ltd., Baghdad 13. Abdul Rahman Al-Allam, Vol. 1, Explanation of the Code of Civil Procedure, Ani Press Baghdad, 1972
14. Abdul Karim Zidan, The Judicial System in Islamic Law, 1st Floor, Al-Ani Press, Baghdad, 1984
15. Abdul Karim Zidan, The Judiciary System in Islamic Sharia, 1st Floor, Al-Ani Press, Baghdad, 1984.
16. Abdellatif Mohamed Ilyas, Opposition to Absentee Judgment, paper submitted to the Council of Justice as part of the conditions for promotion to the second category of judges July, 2002
17. Abdel Moneim Sharkawi, and d. Fathi Wali, Civil and Commercial Procedures, Arab Renaissance House, 1976-1977, p. 155.
18. Ammar Saadoun Hamed, Urgent Justice "Comparative Study", Master Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Law - University of Mosul, 2000.
19. Fathi Wali, Mediator of the Civil Justice Law, 2nd floor, Arab Renaissance House, 1981
20. Louis Maalouf, Upholstered in Language, Literature and Science New Edition.
21. Mohy Hilal Al-Sarhan, Judiciary in Islam, Printed Lectures on Runeo Delivered to Judicial Institute Students, Baghdad, 1990.
22. Medhat Al-Mahmoud, Explanation of Civil Procedure Law, No. 83 of 1969, and its Practical Applications, Part II, Baghdad, 2000.
23. Wagdi Ragheb, Principles of Civil Rivalry, Faculty of Law, Ain Shams University, 1st floor, Publisher Dar Al-Fak al-Arabi, 1978.
Second: Unpublished Judicial Decisions
1. The decision of the Nineveh Court of Appeal as discriminatory on the date of the decision 15/1/1998.
2. Decision of the Court of Cassation No. 356 / I / 98 No. File No. 1074 of 14/4/98
3. The decision of the Nineveh Court of Appeal as discriminatory No. 661 / TB / 99 on 28/8/99
4. Decision of the Nineveh Court of Appeal as discriminatory, No. / 22 / c. B / 2006 on 26/1/2006
5. Decision of the Nineveh Court of Appeal as discriminatory No. 112 / c. B / 2006 on 11/4/2006.